Home Politics Post-Cold War Triumphalism and Kennan’s Warning

Post-Cold War Triumphalism and Kennan’s Warning

- Advertisement -

George F. Kennan in 1947  (Library of Congress) Andrew Bacevich describes how the U.S. learned all the wrong lessons from the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Cold War:You won’t hear it from any of the candidates vying to succeed Trump, but we are still haunted by our false conception of the Cold War. On the stump, politicians get away with reciting comforting clichés about the imperative of American global leadership. Yet the time for believing such malarkey is long gone.An essential first step toward recoupling national security policy and reason is to see the Cold War for what it was: not a “long, twilight struggle” ending in victory, but a vast and costly tragedy that inflicted needless suffering, brought humankind absurdly close to extinction, and from which U.S. policymakers have drawn all the wrong lessons.The anniversary of the fall of the Berlin wall offers an occasion not for celebration but for somber and long overdue reflection.One of the wrong lessons that U.S. policymakers drew from the events of 1989-1991 was that the U.S. was chiefly responsible for ending and “winning” the Cold War, which inevitably overestimated our government’s capabilities and effectiveness in affecting the political fortunes of other parts of the world. The far more critical and important role of the peoples of central and eastern Europe and the Soviet Union itself in overthrowing the system that had oppressed them was pushed into the background as much as possible. The U.S. took credit for their success and policymakers frequently attributed the outcome to the policies of the late Cold War rather than to the deficiencies and failings of the other system. After waging stalemated and failed wars in the name of anticommunism, U.S. policymakers wanted to be able to claim that they had “won” something, and so they declared victory for something that they hadn’t caused.The period that followed the dissolution of the USSR was one of triumphalism, expansion, and overreach. The U.S. not only congratulated itself for achieving something that was accomplished by others, but it also assumed that it could achieve similar results in other parts of the world. If NATO had been a great success as a defensive alliance, the “thinking” went, why shouldn’t it continue and expand to include many more countries? If the U.S. was supposedly able to bring down the Soviet Union, why shouldn’t it do the same to authoritarian regimes elsewhere? Absent the check on ambition and hubris that a superpower rival provided, the U.S. was free to run amok and do whatever it liked without regard for the consequences. That triumphalism sowed the seeds for many of the more significant post-Cold War failures that we have witnessed since then. Even today, that same overconfidence encourages U.S. policymakers to flirt with the idea of engaging in another Cold War-style rivalry with a more formidable state in China.George Kennan presciently warned against the triumphalism that he saw around him as early as 1992. At that time, he was responding directly to the claims from Republicans that Reagan and his policies had “won” the Cold War:The suggestion that any American administration had the power to influence decisively the course of a tremendous domestic-political upheaval in another great country on another side of the globe is intrinsically silly and childish. No great country has that sort of influence on the internal developments of any other one.Kennan went on to say that the militarization of U.S. foreign policy during the Cold War was a boon to Soviet hard-liners and in that way helped prolong it:The extreme militarization of American discussion and policy,
Source:

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Stay Connected

16,985FansLike
2,458FollowersFollow
61,453SubscribersSubscribe

Must Read

UFC 253: Twitter reacts to Jan Blachowicz’s TKO of Dominick Reyes

UFC By Mike Bohn September 27, 2020 12:17 am By Mike Bohn | September 27, 2020 12:17 am Jan Blachowicz will lead the new era of the UFC light heavyweight after claiming the belt against Dominick Reyes on Saturday at UFC 253. After Jon Jones recently gave up the strap, Blachowicz (27-8 MMA, 10-5 UFC)…
- Advertisement -

LeBron James leads Los Angeles Lakers to first NBA Finals in 10 years

11:48 PM ETESPN News Services LAKE BUENA VISTA, Fla. -- LeBron James is going to a 10th NBA Finals -- and for the first time in a decade, so are the Los Angeles Lakers.James punctuated his 27th postseason triple-double with a big fourth quarter, powering the Lakers to a 117-107 victory over the Denver Nuggets…

Tomorrow’s Top 25 Today: Mississippi State jumps in as Big Ten reenters new college football rankings

The college football rankings are set to undergo some major changes after Week 4 action. Not only is the AP Top 25 set to welcome Big Ten teams back into the fold, but the first weekend of SEC play and a big weekend of Big 12 action provided some of the most dramatic results for…

NFL “hopeful” Sunday’s Bears-Falcons game will proceed

Getty Images With Falcons cornerback A.J. Terrell becoming the first player to land on the COVID-19/reserve list during the regular season, that move isn’t necessarily the end of the story — and it’s possibly just the beginning. Mark Maske of the Washington Post reports that the NFL is “hopeful” Sunday’s Bears-Falcons game will proceed as…

Related News

UFC 253: Twitter reacts to Jan Blachowicz’s TKO of Dominick Reyes

UFC By Mike Bohn September 27, 2020 12:17 am By Mike Bohn | September 27, 2020 12:17 am Jan Blachowicz will lead the new era of the UFC light heavyweight after claiming the belt against Dominick Reyes on Saturday at UFC 253. After Jon Jones recently gave up the strap, Blachowicz (27-8 MMA, 10-5 UFC)…

LeBron James leads Los Angeles Lakers to first NBA Finals in 10 years

11:48 PM ETESPN News Services LAKE BUENA VISTA, Fla. -- LeBron James is going to a 10th NBA Finals -- and for the first time in a decade, so are the Los Angeles Lakers.James punctuated his 27th postseason triple-double with a big fourth quarter, powering the Lakers to a 117-107 victory over the Denver Nuggets…

Tomorrow’s Top 25 Today: Mississippi State jumps in as Big Ten reenters new college football rankings

The college football rankings are set to undergo some major changes after Week 4 action. Not only is the AP Top 25 set to welcome Big Ten teams back into the fold, but the first weekend of SEC play and a big weekend of Big 12 action provided some of the most dramatic results for…

NFL “hopeful” Sunday’s Bears-Falcons game will proceed

Getty Images With Falcons cornerback A.J. Terrell becoming the first player to land on the COVID-19/reserve list during the regular season, that move isn’t necessarily the end of the story — and it’s possibly just the beginning. Mark Maske of the Washington Post reports that the NFL is “hopeful” Sunday’s Bears-Falcons game will proceed as…

Trump targets Biden’s mental health in debate lead-up, despite aides’ efforts to raise expectations

President Donald Trump is set to enter the first presidential debate on Tuesday down in the polls, but coming off the high of nominating his third Supreme Court justice. Some top advisers expect a dominant performance by the president, despite the opposing narratives of attacks on Joe Biden's mental state and the Trump campaign's work…
- Advertisement -

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here